Monetize Like Goalhanger: Setting Up a Subscriber Paywall on Your Domain

Beat the discoverability and monetization headache: how Goalhanger scaled to 250k subscribers — and how you can copy the technical blueprint on your own domain

Creators and small teams tell me the same things: “I own my content but I don’t own the customer,” and “I can’t reliably convert social followers into recurring revenue.” If you want a durable subscriber business — not just a few one-off donations — you need a reliable paywall, a domain strategy that protects your brand, and payment infrastructure that scales. Goalhanger’s network hit 250,000 paying subscribers — an instructive case study for creators in 2026. This article breaks down what they did well and gives a step-by-step, practical guide to building your own subscriber paywall on your domain.

Goalhanger now has more than 250,000 paying subscribers across its network, with an average subscriber paying about £60 a year — roughly £15m in annual subscription revenue.

Why Goalhanger matters for creators in 2026

Goalhanger’s growth isn’t only impressive for the raw numbers. It shows a repeatable pattern you can emulate: tightly integrated membership benefits (ad-free content, early access, exclusives), cross-promoting multiple shows, and owning distribution channels like email and Discord. For creators in 2026, the biggest trends that make this replicable are:

• First-party data and direct relationships are king as third-party cookies fade and platforms prioritize privacy.
• Edge hosting and serverless paywalls let small teams scale traffic and handle spikes during launches.
• Stripe Billing, Paddle, and advanced payment orchestration now provide built-in tax handling, dunning, and analytics — reducing engineering overhead.
• Private podcast feeds and tokenized access have matured: creators can serve exclusive audio behind authenticated feeds without relying on platform apps.

What Goalhanger did right — the strategic takeaways

• Multiple entry points: memberships across several shows with centralized billing options.
• Clear benefits: ad-free listening, early access, bonus content, newsletters, community chatrooms, and ticket presales.
• Pricing mix: monthly & annual plans — roughly 50/50 — with an average revenue per user around £60/year.
• Owned channels: email and Discord used for retention and product updates, minimizing social algorithm risk.

Before you code: pick the right domain strategy

Choose a domain setup that balances brand clarity, SEO, and engineering simplicity. Here are three common patterns and when to use them.

Option A — Single brand domain with subpaths

Example: yourbrand.com/members or yourbrand.com/subscribe

• Best for: single creator brands where SEO and a unified presence matter.
• Pros: easy canonicalization, SEO benefits flow to the main site, simpler cookies and analytics.
• Cons: requires careful access control on content paths.

Option B — Subdomain for membership

Example: members.yourbrand.com

• Best for: when you want isolation of stack (different tech) or if you run multiple membership products.
• Pros: clean separation for deployment and scaling, easier to run a headless app specifically for members.
• Cons: you need to ensure SEO and canonical signals are configured, and cross-subdomain cookies or SSO are handled.

Option C — Dedicated domains per show/product

Example: restishistory.com and restispolitics.com with their own paywalls

• Best for: creators running distinct shows or businesses that need unique brands.
• Pros: strong brand clarity for each product, targeted SEO.
• Cons: more operational overhead and duplicate management for payments and user accounts unless centralized.

My recommendation

If you’re a single creator or a small network, use a main brand domain with a members subpath and optionally map branded subdomains for shows. That gives you SEO upside while keeping membership systems unified, which is what helps networks scale like Goalhanger.

Step-by-step paywall architecture checklist

Below is a practical blueprint that covers both simple and advanced setups.

1. Decide product & entitlements
   • List what paying subscribers get: ad-free, early releases, bonus episodes, newsletters, community access, ticket presales.
   • Define tiers and trial rules, e.g., free trial length, student discount, annual vs monthly.
2. Choose your tech stack
   • Quick launch (minimal engineering): Ghost(Pro) or Memberful with a mapped domain.
   • Balanced (control + speed): WordPress with MemberPress or Restrict Content Pro on Kinsta/WP Engine.
   • Scalable & modern: JAMstack with Next.js/SvelteKit, Vercel/Netlify, and Stripe Billing plus serverless functions for webhooks.
3. Pick a payment gateway
   • Stripe Billing for most creators: great global coverage, recurring billing, Stripe Tax, customer portal, and extensive webhooks.
   • Paddle if you want bundled tax/VAT handling with fewer compliance headaches (common for EU creators selling digital goods).
   • PayPal Subscriptions for audience segments that prefer PayPal — use as a fallback option.
4. Implement subscription lifecycle & webhooks
   • Use webhook events (checkout.session.completed, invoice.payment_succeeded, invoice.payment_failed, customer.subscription.updated) to update access in your database.
   • Implement dunning: retry logic, update payment method flows, and email sequences for failed payments.
5. Protect private assets
   • For audio: use signed URLs or tokenized RSS feeds for private podcast subscribers.
   • For video/downloads: host on S3 with expiring pre-signed URLs or use a service like Bunny or Cloudflare R2 + Workers for signed access.
6. Set up authentication & SSO
   • Start with email/password and passwordless magic links. Consider Passkeys/WebAuthn for passwordless reliability by 2026.
   • If you have multiple domains or subdomains, implement SSO so one subscription gives access across properties.
7. Analytics, churn tracking & cohort analysis
   • Measure acquisition channel LTV, churn by cohort, and MRR/ARR. Use GA4, PostHog, or Amplitude with server-side tracking to maintain first-party data fidelity.
8. Compliance & invoicing
   • Enable Stripe Tax or Paddle to handle VAT and sales taxes. Keep clear invoicing and receipts, and prepare for GDPR data subject requests.

Payment gateway comparisons and 2026 considerations

In 2026 the big differences are about tax automation, dunning tools, and international coverage.

• Stripe: strongest developer experience, built-in billing, tax, and customer portal. Use Stripe Checkout to reduce PCI burden and Stripe Billing for subscriptions.
• Paddle: great for EU creators who want the vendor-of-record handling of VAT and compliance, but less developer flexibility.
• Chargebee/Recurly: enterprise grade for complex billing, big teams, and advanced revenue recognition.
• PayPal: supplemental option for audiences that prefer it; consider offering as an alternative checkout.

Hosting: how to choose a host for subscription sites

Your hosting choice affects performance, uptime, and how easy it is to scale during promotions and launches.

Managed WordPress (for editorial creators)

• Providers: Kinsta, WP Engine, and Rocket.net. Use when you need rich CMS features, plugins for memberships, and editorial workflows.

Ghost(Pro) (for newsletters + podcasts)

• Ghost is designed for memberships and subscriptions out of the box. Ghost(Pro) handles hosting, SSL, and payment integration for quick launches.

JAMstack + serverless (for scale)

• Providers: Vercel, Netlify, Fly.io, Render. Ideal for fast sites, edge caching, and atomic deployments. Use serverless functions for webhook handling and entitlement checks.

Podcast-specific hosting

• Paid podcast hosting (Transistor, Libsyn, Supercast) offers private feed handling and analytics. Combine with your own domain for landing pages.

Implementing the paywall: a concrete implementation pattern (JAMstack + Stripe)

Here’s a minimal, practical flow that works for many creators in 2026:

1. User visits yourbrand.com/subscribe and clicks a plan.
2. Client calls your serverless function to create a Stripe Checkout session.
3. Stripe Checkout handles card collection. On success, Stripe fires a checkout.session.completed webhook.
4. Your webhook verifies the event, creates or updates the user record, and issues an access token (JWT) linked to subscription entitlements.
5. User is redirected to a members dashboard where client stores the JWT in secure cookies and uses it to request protected assets.
6. For private podcast RSS: generate a per-user tokenized feed URL and rotate keys periodically. Serve assets from S3 with signed URLs.

Essential webhook events to handle

• checkout.session.completed
• invoice.payment_succeeded
• invoice.payment_failed
• customer.subscription.updated
• customer.subscription.deleted

Retention and product bets modeled on Goalhanger

Goalhanger monetized via a bundle of benefits that increased stickiness. Consider these high-impact retention tactics:

• Exclusive time-lagged content: early access to episodes for members.
• Ad-free consumption: a clear value exchange.
• Community access: Discord rooms and member-only events increase engagement.
• Merch and live presales: early ticket access converts superfans.
• Email-first onboarding: a structured drip sequence to reduce early churn.

Monitoring, security and scale

Plan for launch spikes and fraud protection:

• Use a CDN and edge caching so public pages can handle spikes without origin trips.
• Keep your webhook handler idempotent and retriable — Stripe may send duplicate events.
• Implement rate limiting, WAF (Web Application Firewall), and 2FA for admin interfaces.
• Use signed URLs for private media and rotate keys. Monitor download patterns to detect credential sharing.

Legal, tax and accounting essentials

Don’t underestimate compliance. By 2026 many platforms provide tax automation, but you still need clear billing and refund policies.

• Enable automated tax calculation (Stripe Tax or Paddle).
• Keep clear receipts and invoice records for subscriptions and refunds.
• Prepare for VAT and sales tax implications when selling internationally.

How to test and launch — an actionable launch checklist

1. Smoke test Checkout flows for new and returning customers.
2. Simulate webhook delivery and retries with Stripe CLI or equivalent.
3. Verify private podcast feed access and signed URL expiry times.
4. Run a soft-launch with a small cohort to capture UX issues and churn signals.
5. Measure acquisition channel CAC and projected LTV before scaling paid acquisition.

Advanced strategies and 2026 predictions

Looking forward, the creator subscription landscape will continue to evolve:

• Composability of entitlement systems: expect more headless membership services and SSO patterns that let fans use a single identity across creator sites.
• Passkeys and passwordless: friction for sign-in will drop, improving conversion and retention.
• Creator networks: bundles and cross-sell between shows will increase average revenue per user, which is exactly how Goalhanger aggregated value across shows.
• AI personalization: tailored member recommendations and custom content streams will raise engagement metrics.

Common pitfalls and how to avoid them

• Trying to own everything too early: outsource tax and payment complexity to Paddle or Stripe Tax until you have the scale to justify a custom solution.
• Ignoring churn measurement: track cohorts and implement win-back campaigns.
• Poor onboarding: no amount of marketing will fix a bad first 7 days — prioritize onboarding flows and early value delivery.
• Not protecting assets: unsecured media URLs lead to credential sharing; use signed URLs and monitoring.

Quick implementation recipes

30-minute launch (least technical)

1. Sign up for Ghost(Pro) and map your domain.
2. Connect Stripe for subscriptions and set basic tiers.
3. Publish a members-only post and launch with email to existing followers.

2-week launch (custom experience)

1. Use Next.js on Vercel, set up Stripe Checkout and Billing.
2. Implement serverless webhook handler and JWT-based entitlements.
3. Use S3 + signed URLs for private media and a tokenized podcast RSS generator.

Final thoughts — turn followers into sustainable subscribers

Goalhanger’s 250k paying subscribers are a clear signal: audiences will pay for consistently delivered, differentiated value when you own the relationship and make access easy. The technical pieces aren’t magic — they’re decisions: domain strategy, payment orchestration, hosting resiliency, and above all, a benefits-led product that keeps people subscribed.

If you take one thing from this piece: start with a simple, secure subscription flow on your own domain, track cohort churn from day one, and design member benefits that deepen engagement. Do that, and you’ll have the foundation to scale your subscriber model with confidence.

Call to action

Ready to build a paywall that scales? Start with a technical audit: map your domain plan, pick a payment gateway, and run a 2-week prototype. If you want a tailored checklist for your show or site, click below to get a free template that maps domains to tech stacks and estimated costs for 2026.

Related Reading

• Micro Apps for Menu Planning: Rapid Prototypes for Home Cooks and Chefs
• Cosy Glam: A Winter At-Home Makeup Routine Using Hot-Water Bottles and Ambient Lamps
• How Publishers Can Package Creator Data for Cloudflare-Backed Marketplaces
• Why Requiem on Switch 2 Matters: Hardware, Porting, and What It Means for Nintendo’s Future
• How SSD shortages and rising storage costs affect on-prem PMS and CCTV systems